IELTS Free Online Writing Practice - Should Museums Return Cultural Artifacts to Their Countries of Origin?
IELTS.WORK Free Online Writing Practice # 1711603480
Title: Should Museums Return Cultural Artifacts to Their Countries of Origin?
Task Type: Argumentative Essay
Question: In this essay, you are asked to discuss whether museums should return cultural artifacts to their countries of origin or not. To support your argument, you need to consider the ethical, historical and cultural aspects of this issue, as well as its potential impact on tourism and education.
Model Answer:
In recent years, the return of cultural artifacts to their countries of origin has become a topic of heated debate among scholars, policymakers, and museum professionals worldwide. The primary argument in favor of returning these artifacts is that it represents a step towards rectifying historical wrongs committed by colonial powers. On the other hand, opponents argue that such returns could potentially harm the preservation and study of these artifacts. This essay will discuss both sides of this argument before presenting a balanced conclusion.
Firstly, it can be argued that the return of cultural artifacts is essential for promoting justice and respecting the sovereignty of nations from which they were taken. Many artifacts were acquired through conquest, exploitation, or deception, causing immense suffering to indigenous people. Returning these objects would symbolize an acknowledgement of this wrongdoing and allow countries to reclaim their heritage. For example, the Parthenon Marbles, currently housed in the British Museum, are considered a significant part of Greek cultural identity. Their return would not only reunite them with their rightful nation but also foster national pride and a sense of belonging among Greeks.
Conversely, opponents of artifact repatriation assert that museums play a crucial role in preserving and studying historical artifacts. They argue that removing these objects from their current locations could lead to their deterioration due to lack of expertise or resources in the home countries. Additionally, museums often provide valuable context and interpretation for these artifacts, which may be lost if they are returned without proper documentation and care. Moreover, it has been suggested that the economic benefits derived from tourism outweigh any potential gains from artifact repatriation.
Ultimately, a balanced approach to this issue should involve ongoing dialogue between source countries, museums, and international organizations. While it is essential to recognize the importance of preserving cultural heritage, we must also ensure that these artifacts continue to contribute to global understanding and education. This could be achieved through joint initiatives where both nations collaborate in their care, conservation, and display.
In conclusion, while the return of cultural artifacts to their countries of origin holds significant ethical implications, it is equally important to consider the potential impact on preservation, study, and tourism. By fostering collaboration between source countries, museums, and international organizations, we can strive towards a more equitable and respectful approach that benefits all parties involved.
Band Score (IELTS
Scoring Standards):
- Task Response:
9 - The candidate has fully addressed the task requirement by providing an informative response in the form of an essay.
- Coherence and Cohesion:
8 - The essay is well structured with clear topic sentences, but some minor improvements can be made to improve coherence and cohesion.
- Lexical Resource:
9 - The candidate demonstrates a wide range of vocabulary and idiomatic expressions relevant to the topic.
- Grammatical Range and Accuracy:
8 - Some grammar errors are present, but they do not significantly impede understanding or fluency.
- Presentation of Argument:
9 - The argument is presented clearly with logical flow and appropriate use of evidence to support the points made.
Source:
https://www.ielts.work/?id=1711603480&page=ielts-writing-practice
For more:
https://www.ielts.work/?page=ielts-writing-practice
